Forget the Freshman Fifteen

College Gen Eds Can Make a Lifelong Difference for Young Adults

By Hailey Menjivar

Macey L., a freshman at BYU-Idaho, defies the stereotypes of her peers, simply by eating healthier at college than she did at home.

Macey didn’t have a terrible diet at home in Rigby, Idaho. She felt like she ate okay, but since she moved to Rexburg for school, she beat the odds and is more health-conscious than before. She feels more awake throughout the day and feels full longer.

“I’ve been eating a lot more fruits and vegetables,” she says. “And I’ve been trying to not eat as many processed foods.”

What made the difference? The university introduced Macey to good nutrition through her general education requirements, classes that could change the lives of millions of college students.

As another semester begins in a few weeks, BYU-Idaho and many other schools will receive another influx of freshmen. Many of these students will be away from home for the first time, responsible for managing themselves and their health more than ever. Nutrition is one area where many students will be solely responsible for the first time.

“A lot of students leave home with balanced three meals a day,” says Marinda Taylor, a registered dietician and faculty member at BYU-Idaho. “Then they don’t quite eat the same or eat more convenient foods. And that can promote lifelong health consequences.”

Taylor’s first job was working in a hospital to treat the results of poor nutrition. She now teaches college students so that she can help younger people set life-long habits that prevent the diseases she used to treat.

“Nutrition impacts not just college students, but everybody. Because we have to have fuel to function.”

A 2021 study found that two-thirds of students exceeded the added sugar recommendations. Over half ate too many saturated fats, and about the same amount consumed too much salt. 96% of students ate too many refined grains and too few whole grains. All these factors correlate with a higher risk of cardiovascular disease, high blood pressure, and obesity.

Taylor is familiar with the impact these eating habits have on college students specifically.

“If you’re not taking care of yourself or your health—if you’re not feeding yourself—you’re going to feel run-down and tired,” she says. She gives an example familiar to many students: “If you’re not getting breakfast and you’re sitting in a long lecture, your brain needs glucose to run, and it could make them sluggish and not firing fast enough. They can’t keep up with the lectures.”

She also cites the prevalence of sickness among many students. “Here in Rexburg, Idaho it’s cold all the time, it feels like. You can get run down. Your immune system doesn’t work as well when you don’t fuel your body right.”

More serious issues arise when nutrition choices interact with stress. “I’ve definitely had students with recent diagnoses like celiac disease and stuff like that. And I think stress can kind of turn lights on in a body.”

Taylor refers to genetic markers as lights that can turn on and off in the body. For example, someone may be predisposed to a disease, such as celiac, but that issue doesn’t surface until stress on the body “turns on the light”. In these cases, she says, it is even more important to know how to feed your body.

“College is a very stressful time,” she says, warning against letting your mood control your food. “I see that a little more prevalent in the college years.”

A healthy diet can reduce the symptoms of stress so prevalent among college students. Getting a healthy diet and eating mindfully may decrease feelings of stress, leaving students energized and ready to tackle everyday pressures, according to the Harvard School of Public Health.

However, many students are unaware of the importance of a healthy diet or feel unable to implement one. This is due to a variety of intrinsic and extrinsic factors at play.

 

Intrinsic Factors

College students face several challenges in maintaining a nutritious diet. A study in 2022 evaluated the perceived challenges students face and found many intrinsic and extrinsic factors. These included a lack of willpower, little nutritional knowledge, hectic schedules, food costs and availability, and social influences.

In the study, lack of willpower was the most frequent response. The study suggested that some forms of this, including perceived personal gluttony, are linked to high stress.

Extrinsic Factors

A few extrinsic factors worked with the personal barriers, decreasing nutritious diets in students. Most commonly cited were the high prices of healthy foods, low budgets, social influences, and a lack of food education in childhood.

The cost of food particularly concerned students. Researchers cited the lack of variety and high prices of healthy foods in university canteens. Students at Rexburg will likely be similarly familiar with the number and variety of unhealthy options in the Manwaring Center, Hot Stop Market, and Student Store, as opposed to the healthy options. When students feel short on time, they often turn to these places for meals.

Personal Knowledge

On top of this, many students were unaware of the need to maintain a healthier diet. Researchers wrote, “Our sample of participants were young and is in their peak physical stage; therefore, the effect of bad eating habits might not be visible at present, but will emerge later in their lives.” The students questioned also had poor “food education,” including knowledge of prices and cooking skills, especially among freshmen.

Researchers and students in the study made suggestions for possible solutions. These included encouraging parents to teach kids more about food ingredients and cooking, middle and high school classes, and off-campus social groups to share information.

Taylor, who has worked in both junior high and college settings, felt that college classes were more effective. “It seems like when you pay for your education, you own this education.” When she worked in junior high schools, she had to “almost do a song and dance to keep kids engaged.” She says attention spans in college make the most significant difference in teaching this age group.

The study also suggested that college courses could make a significant difference. A lack of nutritional knowledge was the second largest barrier to freshmen. For non-freshmen students, however, it dropped to sixth place. This may be because participants in the study had completed at least one nutrition course during or after their freshman year. They knew more about nutrition.

Macey learned about the importance of nutrition and how to choose a healthy diet from her college courses. She isn’t a nutrition major, but her general education requirements covered the topic. In her first semester, she took a class called “Sustaining Human Life” as part of her general education requirements. This class has a short section on human nutrition, which helped her take a better look at her eating habits and the long-term consequences. She realized, “I want to be really old when I die, but I don’t want to suffer pain. I want to know my grandkids really well.”

Now she is in the last week of the class, “Essentials of Human Nutrition”, one option for a general science requirement. “I feel like it helped because it gave off a good warning,” Macey says. “If you make a change now, you can prevent problems later.”

Nutrition classes also have resources that wouldn’t otherwise be available to students. Taylor’s class and others at BYU-Idaho use a program called“NutriCalc Plus.” It helps students track personal nutrition recommendations, food intake, and the nutrients they may be getting too little or too much of. Taylor said these tools and the knowledge they gain from using them empower the students.

“I’ve definitely seen a big difference,” she says. “It’s something you’ll use the rest of your life.”

Macey learned more about her specific dietary needs through the NutriCalc Plus tool. “I noticed after working out I need to get a pot more protein. That’s one change I’m trying to work on.” She holds out her arms and explains that she wants to bulk up more for water polo, and now she knows what she needs to do. “I want stronger arms so I can really throw the water polo ball. I noticed I’m a little below the recommendation.” She’s recently added more eggs and lunch meats to her diet.

Students in the study suggested options they would find helpful, such as seminars on nutrition, cooking, budgeting, and time management; using social media to promote nutritional knowledge and information; and healthier food options at the university. Macey recalled the educational posters in her elementary school’s cafeteria, saying that the university could do something similar to remind students to eat healthily.

Conclusion

Thousands of freshmen have signed up for spring semester courses. Hundreds will choose a nutrition class for their science general education requirement. That makes for hundreds of students who will potentially learn how to take care of their bodies. Hundreds of students will learn how to prevent disease for themselves and their families.

As the university continues to offer these courses, maybe students like Macey won’t defy the stereotype anymore. Perhaps they will become the norm.

Sources:

“Stress and Health.” The Nutrition Source, Harvard School of Public Health, Oct. 2021, https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/stress-and-health/.

Wongprawmas R, Sogari G, Menozzi D, Mora C. Strategies to Promote Healthy Eating Among University Students: A Qualitative Study Using the Nominal Group Technique. Front Nutr. 2022 Feb 2;9:821016. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2022.821016. PMID: 35187039; PMCID: PMC8847783.

Ziaul H. Rana, Cara L. Frankenfeld, Erika J. Kennedy, Jaclyn Bertoldo, Lilian De Jonge & Lawrence J. Cheskin (2022) Why don’t college freshmen meet the US dietary guidelines for added sugar, refined grains, sodium, and saturated fat?, Journal of American College Health, DOI: 10.1080/07448481.2021.2024213